Self Critical Evaluation Essay

Writing a Critical Review

A critical review is not to be mistaken for the literature review. A 'critical review' is a complete type of text, discussing one particular article or book in detail. The 'literature review', which also needs to be 'critical', is a part of a larger type of text e.g. a chapter of your dissertation.

Most importantly: Read your article / book as many times as possible, as this will make the critical review much easier.


Contents

1. Read and take notes
2. Organising your writing
3. Summary
4. Evaluation
5. Linguistic features of a critical review
6. Summary language
7. Evaluation language
8. Conclusion language
9. Example extracts from a critical review
10. Further resources


Read and Take Notes

To improve your reading confidence and efficiency, visit our pages on reading.

Further reading: Read Confidently

After you are familiar with the text, make notes on some of the following questions. Choose the questions which seem suitable:

  1. What kind of article is it (for example does it present data or does it present purely theoretical arguments)?
  2. What is the main area under discussion?
  3. What are the main findings?
  4. What are the stated limitations?
  5. Where does the author’s data and evidence come from? Are they appropriate / sufficient?
  6. What are the main issues raised by the author?
  7. What questions are raised?
  8. How well are these questions addressed?
  9. What are the major points/interpretations made by the author in terms of the issues raised?
  10. Is the text balanced? Is it fair / biased?
  11. Does the author contradict herself?
  12. How does all this relate to other literature on this topic?
  13. How does all this relate to your own experience, ideas and views?
  14. What else has this author written? Do these build / complement this text?
  15. (Optional) Has anyone else reviewed this article? What did they say? Do I agree with them?

^ Back to top


Organising your writing

Summary

You first need to summarise the text that you have read. One reason to summarise the text is that the reader may not have read the text.
In your summary, you will

  • focus on points within the article that you think are interesting
  • summarise the author(s) main ideas or argument
  • explain how these ideas / argument have been constructed. (For example, is the author basing her arguments on data that they have collected? Are the main ideas / argument purely theoretical?)

In your summary you might answer the following questions:

    Why is this topic important?
    Where can this text be located? For example, does it address policy studies?
    What other prominent authors also write about this?

^ Back to top


Evaluation

Evaluation is the most important part in a critical review.

Use the literature to support your views. You may also use your knowledge of conducting research, and your own experience. Evaluation can be explicit or implicit.

Explicit evaluation

Explicit evaluation involves stating directly (explicitly) how you intend to evaluate the text.

e.g. "I will review this article by focusing on the following questions. First, I will examine the extent to which the authors contribute to current thought on Second Language Acquisition (SLA) pedagogy. After that, I will analyse whether the authors’ propositions are feasible within overseas SLA classrooms."

Implicit evaluation

Implicit evaluation is less direct. The following section on Linguistic Features of Writing a Critical Review contains language that evaluates the text.

A difficult part of evaluation of a published text (and a professional author) is how to do this as a student. There is nothing wrong with making your position as a student explicit and incorporating it into your evaluation. Examples of how you might do this can be found in the section on Linguistic Features of Writing a Critical Review.

You need to remember to locate and analyse the author’s argument when you are writing your critical review. For example, you need to locate the authors’ view of classroom pedagogy as presented in the book / article and not present a critique of views of classroom pedagogy in general.

^ Back to top


Linguistic features of a critical review

The following examples come from published critical reviews. Some of them have been adapted for student use.

^ Back to top


Summary language

  •     This article / book is divided into two / three parts. First...
  •     While the title might suggest...
  •     The tone appears to be...
  •     Title is the first / second volume in the series Title, edited by...The books / articles in this series address...
  •     The second / third claim is based on...
  •     The author challenges the notion that...
  •     The author tries to find a more middle ground / make more modest claims...
  •     The article / book begins with a short historical overview of...
  •     Numerous authors have recently suggested that...(see Author, Year; Author, Year). Author would also be once such author. With his / her argument that...
  •     To refer to title as a...is not to say that it is...
  •     This book / article is aimed at... This intended readership...
  •     The author’s book / article examines the...To do this, the author first...
  •     The author develops / suggests a theoretical / pedagogical model to…
  •     This book / article positions itself firmly within the field of...
  •     The author in a series of subtle arguments, indicates that he / she...
  •     The argument is therefore...
  •     The author asks "..."
  •     With a purely critical / postmodern take on...
  •     Topic, as the author points out, can be viewed as...
  •     In this recent contribution to the field of...this British author...
  •     As a leading author in the field of...
  •     This book / article nicely contributes to the field of...and complements other work by this author...
  •     The second / third part of...provides / questions / asks the reader...
  •     Title is intended to encourage students / researchers to...
  •     The approach taken by the author provides the opportunity to examine...in a qualitative / quantitative research framework that nicely complements...
  •     The author notes / claims that state support / a focus on pedagogy / the adoption of...remains vital if...
  •     According to Author (Year) teaching towards examinations is not as effective as it is in other areas of the curriculum. This is because, as Author (Year) claims that examinations have undue status within the curriculum.
  •     According to Author (Year)…is not as effective in some areas of the curriculum / syllabus as others. Therefore the author believes that this is a reason for some school’s…

^ Back to top


Evaluation language

  •     This argument is not entirely convincing, as...furthermore it commodifies / rationalises the...
  •     Over the last five / ten years the view of...has increasingly been viewed as ‘complicated’ (see Author, Year; Author, Year).
  •     However, through trying to integrate...with...the author...
  •     There are difficulties with such a position.
  •     Inevitably, several crucial questions are left unanswered / glossed over by this insightful / timely / interesting / stimulating book / article. Why should...
  •     It might have been more relevant for the author to have written this book / article as...
  •     This article / book is not without disappointment from those who would view...as...
  •     This chosen framework enlightens / clouds...
  •     This analysis intends to be...but falls a little short as...
  •     The authors rightly conclude that if...
  •     A detailed, well-written and rigorous account of...
  •     As a Korean student I feel that this article / book very clearly illustrates...
  •     The beginning of...provides an informative overview into...
  •     The tables / figures do little to help / greatly help the reader...
  •     The reaction by scholars who take a...approach might not be so favourable (e.g. Author, Year).
  •     This explanation has a few weaknesses that other researchers have pointed out (see Author, Year; Author, Year). The first is...
  •     On the other hand, the author wisely suggests / proposes that...By combining these two dimensions...
  •     The author’s brief introduction to...may leave the intended reader confused as it fails to properly...
  •     Despite my inability to...I was greatly interested in...
  •     Even where this reader / I disagree(s), the author’s effort to...
  •     The author thus combines...with...to argue...which seems quite improbable for a number of reasons. First...
  •     Perhaps this aversion to...would explain the author’s reluctance to...
  •     As a second language student from ...I find it slightly ironic that such an anglo-centric view is...
  •     The reader is rewarded with...
  •     Less convincing is the broad-sweeping generalisation that...
  •     There is no denying the author’s subject knowledge nor his / her...
  •     The author’s prose is dense and littered with unnecessary jargon...
  •     The author’s critique of...might seem harsh but is well supported within the literature (see Author, Year; Author, Year; Author, Year). Aligning herself with the author, Author (Year) states that...
  •     As it stands, the central focus of Title is well / poorly supported by its empirical findings...
  •     Given the hesitation to generalise to...the limitation of...does not seem problematic...
  •     For instance, the term...is never properly defined and the reader left to guess as to whether...
  •     Furthermore, to label...as...inadvertently misguides...
  •     In addition, this research proves to be timely / especially significant to... as recent government policy / proposals has / have been enacted to...
  •     On this well researched / documented basis the author emphasises / proposes that...
  •     Nonetheless, other research / scholarship / data tend to counter / contradict this possible trend / assumption...(see Author, Year; Author, Year).
  •     Without entering into detail of the..., it should be stated that Title should be read by...others will see little value in...
  •     As experimental conditions were not used in the study the word ‘significant’ misleads the reader.
  •     The article / book becomes repetitious in its assertion that...
  •     The thread of the author’s argument becomes lost in an overuse of empirical data...
  •     Almost every argument presented in the final section is largely derivative, providing little to say about...
  •     She / he does not seem to take into consideration; however, that there are fundamental differences in the conditions of…
  •     As Author (Year) points out, however, it seems to be necessary to look at…
  •     This suggest that having low…does not necessarily indicate that…is ineffective.
  •     Therefore, the suggestion made by Author (Year)…is difficult to support.
  •     When considering all the data presented…it is not clear that the low scores of some students, indeed, reflects…

^ Back to top


Conclusion language

  •     Overall this article / book is an analytical look at...which within the field of...is often overlooked.
  •     Despite its problems, Title offers valuable theoretical insights / interesting examples / a contribution to pedagogy and a starting point for students / researchers of...with an interest in...
  •     This detailed and rigorously argued...
  •     This first / second volume / book / article by...with an interest in...is highly informative...

^ Back to top


Example extracts from a critical review

Writing Critically

If you have been told your writing is not critical enough, it probably means that your writing treats the knowledge claims as if they are true, well supported, and applicable in the context you are writing about. This may not always be the case.

Example extracts from a critical review

In these two examples, the extracts refer to the same section of text. In each example, the section that refers to a source has been highlighted in bold. The note below the example then explains how the writer has used the source material.    


Example a

There is a strong positive effect on students, both educationally and emotionally, when the instructors try to learn to say students’ names without making pronunciation errors (Kiang, 2004).

Use of source material in example a: 

This is a simple paraphrase with no critical comment. It looks like the writer agrees with Kiang. (This is not a good example for critical writing, as the writer has not made any critical comment).        


Example b

Kiang (2004) gives various examples to support his claim that “the positive emotional and educational impact on students is clear” (p.210) when instructors try to pronounce students’ names in the correct way. He quotes one student, Nguyet, as saying that he “felt surprised and happy” (p.211) when the tutor said his name clearly. The emotional effect claimed by Kiang is illustrated in quotes such as these, although the educational impact is supported more indirectly through the chapter. Overall, he provides more examples of students being negatively affected by incorrect pronunciation, and it is difficult to find examples within the text of a positive educational impact as such.

Use of source material in example b: 

The writer describes Kiang’s (2004) claim and the examples which he uses to try to support it. The writer then comments that the examples do not seem balanced and may not be enough to support the claims fully. This is a better example of writing which expresses criticality.

^Back to top

^ Back to top


Further resources

You may also be interested in our page on criticality, which covers criticality in general, and includes more critical reading questions.

Further reading: Read and Write Critically

We recommend that you do not search for other university guidelines on critical reviews. This is because the expectations may be different at other institutions. Ask your tutor for more guidance or examples if you have further questions.

^ Back to top

self evaluation report essay self assessment essay sample how to write a self assessment essay self assessment essay sample how to write a self assessment essay.

Essay sample HURIER Listening Self Assessment Essay sample HURIER Listening Self Assessment.

essays on self assessment Sample Templates self essays atsl my ip meself evaluation essays on writing types of validity in research writing.

example satire essay writing a satire essay satirical essay topics critical evaluation essay example socialsci co tender buttons how to write a evaluation essay evaluation essay.

self analysis essays self assessment essay template pdf critical .

Self analysis essay samples Self Reflection Essay Sample Reflective How To Write A Download File.

self control essay sample argumentative essay sample for AppTiled com Unique App Finder Engine Latest Reviews Market News.

self evaluation essay.

Writing the self assessment essay Carpinteria Rural Friedrich Self assessment essay Chapter assessment answer papers tests pdf self assessment strategies and writing styles and tgt sample self.

reflection paper essay group reflection paper essay evaluation a good example essay for self introduction world check out our top essays on self introduction.

self assessment reflective essay example.

essay on self self reflection for persuasive essay self assessment .

reflection paper essay group reflection paper essay evaluation Voluntary Action Orkney.

assessment english essay free self.

Self Assessment Essay Sample Examples in Word PDF .

brief essay format short essay format example sample college Essay evaluation Self assignment lord.

evaluation essay evaluation essay outline what is an evaluation example of self assessment essayassessment essay sample self reflection essay example academic essay self assessment and.

brief essay format short essay format example sample college SlidePlayer Central Nervous System Outline .

Self Assessment Examples Self Kjlhywki Cover Letter.

self assessment essay outline AppTiled com Unique App Finder Engine Latest Reviews Market News.

Sample essay on self reflection dravit si cover letter Examples Of Self Assessmentreflective Essay Sample Assessment Essays Examples Good Critical Analysis Xself essay.

Write self evaluation essay Essay on self Causes and effects of the great depression essay Ut thesiscls Essay on self Causes and effects of the great depression essay Ut thesiscls.

Self introduction essay All About Essay Example Galle Co Self introduction essay All About Essay Example Galle Co.

sample self evaluation essay lok lehrte Carpinteria Rural Friedrich Essay Examples Of Evaluative Essays How To Write An Evaluation.

writing self assessment essay Pinterest Self Evaluation Essay Examples AppTiled com Unique App Finder Engine Latest Reviews Market News.

self assessment essays How To Write A Self Assessment Essay Evaluation Sample.

self assessment essay .

self assessment essay outline.

selfassessment essays example of self assessment essayassessment essay sample self reflection essay example academic essay self assessment and.

College assessment essay examples.

reflective essay self reflective essay on yourself reflective academic essay cultural self awareness and cross cultural team buil topgradepapers com.

Essay Critical Evaluation Essay Sample Sample Of Critical All About Essay Example Galle Co essay writing.

Self Assessment Essay Sample Examples in Word PDF self analysis essayself analysis essay english self assessment examples essay example essay of self.

self help essay writing a writer self in a w i need help writing a essay helalinden com AppTiled com Unique App Finder Engine Latest Reviews Market News.

Writing an evaluation essay Carpinteria Rural Friedrich Essay Assessment Essay Sample self assessment essay.

Self analysis essay samples.

evaluation essay evaluation essay outline what is an evaluation .

Course self evaluation essay Carpinteria Rural Friedrich.

Understand Your GMAT Score Report Self assessment mba essay format How To Write A Self Assessment Carpinteria Rural Friedrich.

Sample Self Assessment Essay Synthesis Example Cover Letter Ascend Surgical Sales Cover Letter Self Assessment Essay Previewself assessment essays.

essays on self assessment How to write a self assessment essay.

Essay Examples Of Evaluative Essays How To Write An Evaluation Carpinteria Rural Friedrich.

Self Assessment Essay Sample Examples in Word PDF All About Essay Example.

Sample essay on self reflection jiyuuyonmdns.

selfassessment essays Essay Assessment Essay Sample self assessment essay.

Self Assessment Reflective Essay Example Topics and Samples Online Self Assessment Reflective Essay Example Topics and Samples Online Ascend Surgical.

english essays examples english self assessment examples essay research paper conclusion examples good english essays an.

Evaluation Essay Introduction Example essay college self evaluation essay examples .

self description essay lok lehrte Argumentative essay definition writefiction web fc com Argumentative essay definition writefiction web fc com.

selfassessment essays.

Course self evaluation essay Iqchallenged Digital Rights Management Resume Sample Teacher Understand Your GMAT Score Report Self assessment mba essay format How To Write A Self Assessment.

essay self introduction examples of self introduction essay Sample Templates.

Class participation self evaluation essay SlideShare essay on self help group in hindi.

Self Assessment Essay Examples Self And Reflection Paper Cover Letter.

self evaluation sample essayself assessment essays miss brill theme essay for of mice sample self assessment.

self essays essays about myself help writing an essay about myself Iqchallenged Digital Rights Management Resume Sample Teacher .

self essay example self introduction essay writing an evaluation .

Writing an evaluation essay Voluntary Action Orkney Self Evaluation Essay Examples Clasifiedad Com What to include in an evaluation essay.

safety essay doc essay health and safety method statement template Carpinteria Rural Friedrich.

Essays on self assessment.

Self analysis essay samples.

selfassessment essays Sample Templates .

self assessment essay outline .

evaluation paper jiyuuyonmdns Cover Letter Self Assessment Examples Self Kjlhywkiself assessment essays Full Size .

Self assessment and reflection reference paper AppTiled com Unique App Finder Engine Latest Reviews Market News Reflection Essays How To Write A Reflective Essay Self Reflection.

Self Assessment Essay Paper venja co Resume And Cover Letter.

self analysis essays self analysis essays wwwgxart self analysis Buy essay online safe Ssays for sale about myself essay help writing an essay about myself help essay about myself introduction custom paper.

write essay about myself Tips For Writing A College Essay About Yourself ideas about Math Worksheet Lucaya International School.

Self evaluation essays on writing Evaluation essay samples dailynewsreport web fc com FC Evaluation essay samples.

sample self evaluation essay lok lehrte All About Essay Example Self Assessment Reflective Essay Example Topics and Samples Online Self Assessment Reflective Essay Example Topics and Samples Online.

How to write an evaluation report of a project writing summary essay essay scorer dwyer middle.

Essay Self Assessment Essay Assessment Essay Sample Picture Help essays Is the death penalty effective argumentative essay The purpose of an evaluation essay is.

Understand Your GMAT Score Report Self assessment mba essay format How To Write A Self Assessment AppTiled com Unique App Finder Engine Latest Reviews Market News.

examples essays essays examples gxart ideas about essay essays examples gxart orgsat essay examples college essays Diamond Geo Engineering Services.

assessment essays Example essays Skills Hub University of Sussex.

Class participation self evaluation essay .

self description essay lok lehrte.

How do you write a self evaluation essay Original content How do you write a self evaluation essay Original content Diamond Geo Engineering Services.

Self Assessment Essay Sample Cover Letter Lucaya International School.

self assessment essay how to write a self assessment essay .

How To Write An Evaluation Essay Evaluation Essay Writing Help.

Sample essay on self reflection.

reflective essay self reflective essay on yourself reflective READ MORE Essay Critical Evaluation Essay Sample Sample Of Critical All About Essay Example Galle Co essay writing.

Assessment of essay lenght Lucaya International School.

Essay about myself sample Critical Self Assessment Essay Sample Clasifiedad Com Critical Self Assessment Essay Sample Clasifiedad Com.

Self evaluation essays on writing Evaluation essay samples dailynewsreport web fc com FC Evaluation essay samples.

Write self evaluation essay READ MORE Sample Self Assessment Essay.

Write self evaluation essay.

assessment essays sample essay about yourself for scholarship sample essay about yourself statement information nmctoastmasters self introduction essay.

Self analysis essay samples Spire Opt Out.

sample self evaluation essay lok lehrte Diamond Geo Engineering Services cover letter Examples Of Self Assessmentreflective Essay Sample Assessment Essays Examples Good Critical Analysis Xself essay.

Review essay tips.

Self Assessment Essay Examples Self And Reflection Paper Cover Letter ESL Energiespeicherl sungen Cover Letter Self Assessment Examples Self Kjlhywkiself assessment essays Full Size .

Essay Self Assessment Essay Assessment Essay Sample Picture AppTiled com Unique App Finder Engine Latest Reviews Market News evaluation paper Outline for essay.

evaluation essay example Lucaya International School.

Self Assessment For Students Writing Communication Center Free Examples Essay And Paper self reflection essay sample reflective how to write a self reflection essay sample self reflective essay.

0 thoughts on “Self Critical Evaluation Essay”

    -->

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *